AQASIA: does limitation apply to bulk or liquid cargo?

Article04.11.20268 mins read

Key takeaways

Package/unit limitation in Hague Rules

Does not apply to bulk or liquid cargo.

Meaning of package/unit

In context of Hague Rules, these are physical items, not units of measurement.

Hague-Visby Rules

Weight limitation does apply to bulk cargo.

Sea Tank Shipping AS -v- Vinnlustodin HF Vatryggingafelg Islands FH (Aqasia) [2018] EWCA Civ 276

For most of a century, the question of whether the "package or unit" limitation in Article IV Rule 5 of the Hague Rules applied to bulk cargo remained open in English law. The Court of Appeal answered the question in The Aqasia: it does not!

On this basis, where a contract of carriage incorporates the 1924 Hague Rules and the cargo is carried in bulk, whether dry or liquid, the carrier has no limitation of liability under those Rules.

Eight years on, many owners and clubs continue to face potentially uncapped exposure. Bulk and liquid cargo values have increased significantly. Parcel tanker trades increasingly carry high-value chemical and biofuel cargoes. Many standard forms still incorporate the Hague Rules rather than the Hague-Visby Rules.

The background facts

The vessel loaded a bulk cargo of fish oil in Iceland for carriage to Norway under a charterparty incorporating the Hague Rules. On arrival, part of the cargo was damaged. Cargo interests claimed US$367,836 in respect of 547,309 kg.

Owners accepted that damage had occurred but sought to limit liability under Article IV Rule 5. They argued that ‘unit’ meant the unit of measurement used in the contract (typically kilograms or metric tonnes). In this case, that limitation would have been £54,730.90.

The Court of Appeal decision

The Court of Appeal rejected that argument and held that "unit" means a physical item of cargo rather than a unit of measurement.

Key reasons:

  1. The words ‘package or unit’ appear together. ‘Package’ is plainly a physical item. ‘Unit’ should therefore also refer to a physical item of cargo.

  2. Article III Rule 3(b) distinguishes between packages or pieces and quantity or weight. This supports the distinction between physical items and measurement units.

  3. The travaux préparatoires showed that limitation by reference to weight, volume or freight was deliberately abandoned. The word ‘unit’ was introduced to cover unpackaged items such as cars or boilers, not bulk cargo.

As bulk cargo consists of neither packages nor physical units, Article IV Rule 5 cannot apply. Under the unamended Hague Rules, liability for loss of or damage to bulk or liquid cargo is therefore unlimited, subject only to any applicable global limitation regime.

Alternative regimes

The Hague-Visby Rules provide an alternative weight-based limitation of two SDRs per kilogramme of gross weight. That limitation applies effectively to bulk cargo.

In contrast, US COGSA permits limitation by reference to the ‘customary freight unit’, which US courts have applied to bulk shipments.

For a total loss on a tanker or bulker, the remaining protection may be the global limitation regime under the Convention on Limitation of Liability for Maritime Claims 1976, as amended.

Drafting options for owners

Owners cannot change the law, but they can change the contractual position.

  1. Express incorporation of the Hague-Visby Rules

    The simplest solution is a clause paramount incorporating the Hague-Visby Rules contractually. The weight-based limitation then applies to bulk cargo. Care is required, however, as a clause referring merely to the Hague Rules as enacted in the country of shipment may leave the unamended Hague Rules in place.
     

  2. Agree an express limitation figure

    Parties may agree a contractual cap. This could be expressed as a specified amount per metric tonne or as an overall voyage limit. The drafting must be clear and must expressly cover bulk cargo and the relevant heads of loss. Note, however, that where the contractual limit is lower than that prescribed compulsorily by any applicable regime (ie the Hague-Visby rules as applied under UK law) this lower limit will be void.

Watch the chain

The exposure often arises across multiple contracts.

A disponent owner may face unlimited liability under a Hague Rules bill of lading while having only limited contractual recovery rights elsewhere in the contractual chain.

For example, if the head charter incorporates the Hague-Visby Rules or contains an express limitation clause, but the bill of lading does not, the intermediate party may absorb the difference.

Owners and operators should therefore review clause paramount wording at every contractual level and assess the impact before any casualty occurs.

Checklist for owners and claims handlers

  1. Identify which liability regime applies under each contract in the chain.

  2. Check clause paramount wording against the relevant ports of shipment.

  3. For bulk and liquid cargo trades on Hague Rules terms, raise the limitation issue during fixture negotiations.

  4. Consider incorporating the Hague-Visby Rules or an express contractual cap.

  5. Following a bulk or liquid cargo carrier casualty subject to the Hague Rules, assess the availability of global limitation under the 1976 Convention at an early stage.

  6. Review standard forms and long-term contracts of affreightment for legacy paramount clauses.

Conclusion

The Aqasia settled this long-standing question in favour of cargo interests. Owners should therefore treat the absence of a cargo claim limitation as settled law. Protection can still be achieved through careful drafting, including incorporation of the Hague-Visby Rules, or an express contractual cap.

For owners trading bulk cargoes on Hague Rules terms, the issue should be addressed at the fixture stage rather than after a casualty.

Find out more about our Shipping expertise or contact us today to discuss how we can support you.

You may also be interested in

Your content, your way

Tell us what you'd like to hear more about.

Subscribe to our news and insights

Related views