Key takeaways
Foreign illegality doctrine
To apply, performance of contractual obligation must be illegal in place of performance.
Foreign injunction restraining payment
Reasonable efforts still required to achieve lawful performance unless futile.
On demand bonds
These are autonomous and will be enforced absent fraud or other very limited exceptions.
A Spanish bank has argued that it could not honour otherwise valid demands for payment under two English law on demand bonds because of a Spanish court injunction restraining payment.
The English Court rejected this argument. Payment was requested to be made to a Mozambique bank account. The place of performance of the payment obligation was, therefore, Mozambique not Spain. Performance was not illegal in Mozambique, only in Spain. The foreign illegality doctrine did not, therefore, apply.
The background facts
The key facts are below:
The underlying dispute arose out of the construction of a power plant in Mozambique. Central Térmica De Temane SA (CTT) engaged TSK Electrónica y Electricidad, S.A. (Spain) and TSK Moçambique Limitada (Mozambique) (together, TSK) under an EPC contract.
To secure various aspects of the contract, Santander issued two on-demand bonds in favour of CTT, namely an advance payment bond and a performance bond (together, the Bonds).
The dispute arose when TSK purported to terminate its contract with CTT by reason of a force majeure event. CTT disputed that termination and, on 4 April 2025, made demands under the Bonds to Santander requiring payment to its Mozambique bank (the Demands).
Under the terms of the Bonds, Santander had five business days to make payment, resulting in a payment deadline of 11 April 2025.
On 10 April 2025, the day before payment fell due, TSK obtained an ex parte interim injunction from the Spanish courts restraining Santander from fulfilling any request for payment of the Bonds.
Santander accepted that the Demands complied with the requirements of the Bonds but declined to make payment on the basis that it was prohibited from doing so by the Spanish interim injunction.
CTT subsequently issued English Court proceedings, seeking payment under the Bonds. Santander’s sole defence was that payment would be unlawful by reason of the Spanish injunction, relying on the principle established in Ralli Brothers -v- Compania Naviera Sota y Aznar [1920] 2 KB 287, namely that the performance of contractual obligations cannot be enforced if performance would be illegal in the place of performance.
Issues for determination
The Court was asked to determine the following issues:
Was the Spanish injunction capable of excusing Santander's obligation to make payment under the Bonds?
If so, where was Santander's payment obligation under the Bonds to be performed: (i) Mozambique, where payment was to be made to CTT's nominated account, or (ii) Spain, where the Demands were submitted and processed?
Was Santander entitled to rely on the principle in Ralli Brothers despite not having taken any steps to discharge the Spanish interim injunction?
Was Santander entitled to rely on Ralli Brothers where it had an opportunity to pay before being notified of the Spanish interim injunction?
The Commercial Court decision
The Court found in favour of CCT, concluding that:
Santander’s obligation under the Bond was to make payment to the account nominated in the Demands. Whilst certain steps were to be taken in Spain before payment could be made, those steps did not themselves constitute Santander's payment obligation. Mozambique was, therefore, the place of performance, not Spain.
The Spanish injunction did not make payment unlawful in Mozambique.
Santander was therefore unable to rely on Ralli Brothers to avoid its obligation to pay under the Bonds.
The Court also noted that, even if the Spanish injunction was capable of engaging the Ralli Bros principle, Santander had not demonstrated that it had made ’reasonable efforts’ to bring about lawful performance (i.e., discharge or vary the injunction) or that any such intervention would have been futile, which it was required to do if it wanted to rely on a foreign illegality defence.
The Court also rejected Santander’s application for a stay of execution or a deferred payment order, finding that demand bonds are intended to provide prompt payment against a valid demand, and that a stay or deferred payment order would undermine that purpose.
Comment
Interestingly, and contrary to the view of the Court in Litasco SA -v- Banque El Amanda SA [2025] EWHC 312 (Comm), the Court in this case found that unlawfulness by reason of a breach of court order was not outside the realms of the foreign illegality doctrine (i.e., the Ralli Bros principle). Instead, Santander’s defence failed due to the place of performance, which was determined by establishing the place of payment.
The decision also serves as a reminder that the English Court will recognise and uphold the autonomous nature of demands bonds by enforcing them absent evidence of fraud or one of the other narrowly defined exceptions to enforcement.
Find out more about our Commodities expertise or contact us today to discuss how we can support you.
This article was co-authored by Associate, Paula Mas Alvarez.

