Court finds LMAA arbitration validly commenced and sole arbitrator effectively appointed

Article18.11.20267 mins read

Key takeaways

Institutional arbitral rules

Rules of arbitral institution or association may modify the default statutory rules.

Effective commencement of arbitration

In commercial dispute, notice or request for arbitration not construed too strictly.

Request for arbitration

Must contain all the required and relevant information in order to be valid.

This dispute highlights that the Court will discount overly legalistic and formalistic arguments when deciding whether a notice of commencement of arbitration satisfies the requirements and is valid. This reflects the fact that commercial parties who choose to arbitrate do so because they wish to avoid technical complexity or formality for their own sake.

The background facts

The contract

By a written agreement dated 27 July 2024, the claimants, as owner and disponent owner, agreed to sell their vessel to the first defendant as buyer, with the second defendant acting as the buyer’s guarantor.

Article 16 of the contract provided for English law and LMAA arbitration in London in accordance with LMAA Rules, with three arbitrators to be appointed pursuant to the Rules.

LMAA Terms

Para 8(b) of the LMAA Terms provides:

‘Subject to the terms of the arbitration agreement, if the tribunal is to consist of three arbitrators: (i) each party shall appoint one arbitrator not later than 14 days after service of a request in writing by either party to do so; …’

Para. 10 provides:

‘A party wishing to refer a dispute to arbitration in accordance with paragraph 8(b)(i) … above shall appoint its arbitrator and send notice of such appointment in writing to the other party, requiring the other party to appoint its own arbitrator within 14 calendar days of the notice, and stating that the requesting party will appoint its own arbitrator as sole arbitrator unless the other party appoints its own arbitrator and gives notice that it has done so within the 14 days specified. If the other party does not appoint its own arbitrator and give notice that it has done so within the 14 days specified in the notice, the party referring a dispute to arbitration may, without the requirement of any further prior notice to the other party, appoint its arbitrator as sole arbitrator and shall advise the other party accordingly. The award of a sole arbitrator appointed in this manner shall be binding on both parties as if the sole arbitrator had been appointed by agreement.’

Request for arbitration

A dispute arose between the parties. On 25 January 2025, the buyer’s Turkish lawyers wrote to the seller, enclosing a ‘Request for Arbitration’ (the Request). This document was comprehensive, containing all the details that would normally be provided when giving notice of a claim and the intention to commence arbitration proceedings. The document also enclosed a copy of the LMAA Terms and stated that the Request was filed pursuant to para. 10 of the LMAA Rules 2021.

The Request was served on the sellers and their solicitors, and the sellers indicated they were prepared for arbitration. They did not, however, appoint their own arbitrator.

Appointment as sole arbitrator

On 30 January 2025, the buyer made a submission to the arbitrator including a request to him to accept appointment as sole arbitrator. The sellers were copied in but took no action.

On 13 February 2025, the arbitrator purportedly did accept that invitation, acknowledging his appointment as sole arbitrator.

Objection

In April 2025, the sellers commenced court proceedings challenging the validity of the sole arbitrator appointment and seeking an appointment under s.18 of the Arbitration Act 1996 (1996 Act), which applies where there is a failure of the arbitrator appointment procedure.

Arbitration award

The sole arbitrator declined to stay arbitration proceedings pending the outcome of the sellers’ application. He published an award, finding against the sellers.

The sellers applied under ss.67 and 68 of the 1996 Act, challenging the arbitrator’s jurisdiction and claiming serious irregularity leading to substantial injustice.

The relevant provisions

1996 Act

S.14(4) of the 1996 Act is the default rule dealing with when arbitration is commenced. However, it is not mandatory, and the parties are free to agree when arbitral proceedings are to be regarded as commenced.

Under s.15(1) of the 1996 Act, the parties are free to agree on the number of arbitrators.

Under s.16 (1) the parties can agree on the procedure for appointing an arbitrator or arbitrators. The default rules, which apply when they have not agreed on a procedure and there are three arbitrators, are that ‘each party shall appoint one arbitrator not later than 14 days after service of a request in writing by either party to do so’, and the arbitrators so appointed select the third: s.16(5).

Under s.17 of the 1996 Act, if each party is to appoint an arbitrator and one of them refuses to do so or fails to do so within the time specified, the party that has duly appointed an arbitrator may give notice to the party in default that he proposes to appoint his arbitrator to act as sole arbitrator.

In that event, unless the defaulting party appoints an arbitrator within seven clear days and notifies the other party that he has done so, the appointed arbitrator may be appointed as sole arbitrator, and his award is binding on the parties. In that event, however, the Court retains power to set aside the appointment.

These provisions all apply unless the parties otherwise agree.

LMAA Terms

These modify the statutory provisions as follows:

  1. A party seeking to commence an arbitration must appoint its own arbitrator and send notice requiring appointment by the other party. This modifies s.14(4), in that a valid commencement of an LMAA arbitration when the agreement provides for a three-person tribunal needs both a notice requiring appointment by the other party (as the 1996 Act does) and appointment by a party of its own arbitrator (which the 1996 Act does not).

  2. Instead of the procedure under s.17 of the 1996 Act whereby the non-defaulting party must wait until the period for appointment has elapsed, and then give the other party a separate notice threatening to appoint its own arbitrator as sole arbitrator, and then wait seven clear days, the LMAA Terms provide for the arbitration notice itself to contain a requirement to appoint within 14 calendar days, failing which the requesting party may appoint its own arbitrator as sole arbitrator.

  3. In further modification of s.17, they do not provide for such an appointment to be set aside by the Court.

The sellers’ arguments

The sellers argued that the Request was not valid because it did not: (a) require the other party to appoint its arbitrator within 14 days, or (b) state that the claimant would appoint its own arbitrator as sole arbitrator unless the other party appointed its own arbitrator and gave notice that it had done so within the 14 days specified.

Therefore, the sellers argued that the buyers could not rely on para.10 of the LMAA Terms to appoint their arbitrator as sole arbitrator. They could only rely on s.17 of the 1996 Act which they had not done.

The Commercial Court decision

The Court highlighted that the intention of English arbitration law, as recognised in the 1996 Act, is to make arbitration a flexible and practical institution for resolving commercial disputes, and to avoid technical traps. In a commercial dispute, a letter requesting arbitration should not be construed too strictly.

The LMAA Terms, in requiring a notice of arbitration to require the other party to appoint their own arbitrator, reflected the language of the 1996 Act. The case law established that the necessary requirement could be implied, it need not be express. A notification by one party to the other party that it wished to submit a dispute to arbitration in accordance with their agreement was sufficient to commence the arbitration because it was by implication a request to the other party to appoint their own arbitrator.

If the demand to appoint an arbitrator could be implied, then the statement about what would occur if that did not occur, ie the appointment of the arbitrator as sole arbitrator, could also be implied. There was nothing in the 1996 Act that required any momentous formality if the parties were to agree to a procedure which departed from s.17. All that was required was the parties' agreement. Agreeing to the application of institutional or association rules constituted such an agreement.

The parties here had expressly agreed to the LMAA Terms and so were taken to know that, under the LMAA Terms, a respondent to an arbitration has 14 days to appoint an arbitrator, and that failing appointment the existing arbitrator may become sole arbitrator.

The buyers expressly referred to para.10 of the LMAA Terms and invoked them, and they included a copy of the Terms with their notice.

The sellers must be taken to have understood that (a) they were being called upon to appoint an arbitrator and (b) if they did not do so, the buyer's appointed arbitrator might become sole arbitrator. If asked what would happen if they did not make an appointment within 14 days, the sellers would have understood that the buyer might invoke its right under para. 10 to appoint its arbitrator as sole arbitrator. The consequences of not appointing an arbitrator were clear to anyone who read the Request with care.

The jurisdictional challenge was therefore dismissed. The Court also dismissed the serious irregularity challenge, which alleged apparent bias on the part of the arbitrator. The sole arbitrator was entitled to continue with the arbitration proceedings pending the court challenge brought by the sellers. This did not constitute apparent bias. Nor was it relevant that the sole arbitrator was a Turkish lawyer and therefore shared nationality with the buyer. The LMAA Terms did not impose any requirements as to nationality, nor could nationality be regarded as suspicious in a commercial shipping case.

Comment

The case provides a good reminder to those agreeing to arbitrate pursuant to institutional or association rules that said rules may modify the default rules under the 1996 Act.

They should, therefore, ensure that they are familiar with the applicable institutional or association rules and that they comply with them. Whilst the Court may be flexible in its interpretation of a notice to commence arbitration, ticking all the boxes expressly in line with the applicable rules may avoid disputes of this nature.

Find out more about our Shipping team or contact us today to discuss how we can support you.

You may also be interested in

Your content, your way

Tell us what you'd like to hear more about.

Preference centre

Related views