Court of Appeal confirms ICSID Convention awards are not assignable

Article17.11.20267 mins read

Key takeaways

International investment treaties

Customary international law applies.

ICSID Convention award

These are not assignable.

Commercial context

Emerging practice of monetising award rights and avoiding enforcement issues by assigning awards.

In an earlier article, we reported on the Commercial Court decision in this case, in which the Court held that rights under an ICSID Convention arbitration award are not assignable.

The Court of Appeal has now dismissed the appeal from the Commercial Court decision and confirmed that, as a matter of international law as it currently stands, an ICSID Convention award against a contracting State, in this case the Kingdom of Spain (Spain), is not assignable.

The Court of Appeal’s view differs from that taken in some other jurisdictions, including first instance decisions from Australia and the United States arising out of litigation relating to other investment treaty arbitrations against Spain.

However, the Court of Appeal concluded that there was no clear international consensus that it was obliged to follow and it was, therefore, entitled to decide the issue for itself.

The background facts

The Spanish legislation and renewables tariff regime

From 1997 onwards, a Spanish legislative regime offered significant incentives for the production of energy from renewable sources, and in particular solar energy. The subsequent amendment of that legislation between 2010 and 2014 resulted in modifications to the tariff regime that were alleged to be detrimental to those who had invested in the production of renewable energy in Spain and caused substantial losses.

Investment treaty arbitration

As a result, 51 arbitrations have been commenced against Spain under the Energy Charter Treaty 1994 (ECT) and litigation arising from those awards has reached the courts of eight countries.

In this case, Operafund Eco-Invest Sicav Plc and Schwab Holding AG (the Investors) are companies incorporated in Malta and Switzerland respectively (both contracting states to the ECT and the ICSID Convention) who had invested in a number of solar energy plants in Spain.

They commenced arbitration against Spain under the ECT in July 2015, pursuant to Article 26 of the ECT, which offers an investor seeking to bring a claim under its provisions a number of dispute resolution options.

The Investors opted to bring their claims under the rules of the ICSID Convention. They obtained a final award in their favour in October 2019 in the sum of €29.3m (the Award). Spain failed to have the Award annulled under Article 52 of the ICSID Convention, which is the only means by which the Convention permits an ICSID award to be challenged.

Enforcement and state immunity challenge

In August 2021, the Investors obtained an order without notice under s.2 of the Arbitration (International Investment Disputes) Act 1966 (the 1966 Act) to register the Award as if it were a judgment of the English Court. Spain applied to have the order set aside on the ground of state immunity.

A decision on the state immunity challenge was adjourned pending the outcome of other enforcement proceedings in respect of an ECT award against Spain arising from the same amendments to the renewable tariffs regime. In Infrastructure Services Luxembourg SARL -v- Kingdom of Spain [2023] EWHC 1226 (Comm), the Court had dismissed Spain’s state immunity challenge, but an appeal decision was pending.

Subsequently, in October 2024, the Court of Appeal dismissed Spain’s state immunity challenge in Infrastructure Services. In March 2026, the Supreme Court upheld that decision.

Assignment

In January 2024, the Investors had purported to assign all their rights under the Award to Blasket Renewable Investments Plc (Blasket) pursuant to an Assignment Agreement governed by Swiss law.

Blasket, a company incorporated under the laws of Delaware, was incorporated for the purposes of acquiring and exploiting investment treaty awards. Award creditors purport to assign their award rights to third parties such as Blasket as a way of monetising the award and avoiding the risks and burden of seeking to enforce the award.

In July 2024, Blasket applied for an order that it be substituted for the Investors in Spain’s set-aside application.

The Commercial Court decision

The Court refused the substitution application on the basis that, properly construed, Article 54(2) of the ICSID Convention permitted only an original party to an ICSID Convention award to seek registration and enforcement of that award.

In particular having regard to Article 15 of the ECT, rights arising under the ECT and arbitration awards giving effect to such rights were not assignable without the contracting state's consent.

The treaties

The ECT is a multilateral investment treaty, with signatory states undertaking obligations to each other in relation to qualifying investments made by nationals of other signatories within their territory, which obligations are capable of being enforced by those qualifying nationals in accordance with Article 26 of the ECT.

Qualifying investors are not parties to the ECT but the claims an investor asserts under the treaty's dispute resolution provisions under Article 26 are its own claims, with the treaty giving direct rights to qualifying investors, not those of its state.

Article 54 of the ICSID Convention provides for ‘a party’ to seek the recognition and enforcement of awards by contracting states.

The Court of Appeal decision

The Court of Appeal has dismissed the appeal and agreed with the Commercial Court that there was no relevant right of assignment in this case.

Its key findings were as follows:

  1. The assignability of an ICSID Convention award is governed by customary international law.

  2. The ECT and ICSID Conventions neither expressly confer a right to assign nor expressly prohibit the assignment of a treaty arbitration award.

  3. There is no international convention addressing the assignability of international treaty rights generally. This ‘silence’ was not, however, permissive and should not be interpreted as meaning there was no prohibition on such an assignment.

  4. On the current state of customary international law, treaty rights as between states are not assignable without the consent of the obligor state, either given in advance in the treaty or subsequently.

  5. That should apply equally to non-state investors, who only gain rights against a host state if they meet a number of qualifying criteria. It would be surprising if such investors, who were non-parties to the treaty but who benefited from direct rights under it, could assign their rights when a state could not.

  6. The international authorities indicated there were substantial differences of opinion and practice on the assignability of investor rights under investment treaties. There was, therefore, no established uniform customary international law on the issue that bound the Court of Appeal.

  7. Pursuant to s.54(2) of the ICSID Convention, only a party to an ICSID Convention award could seek its recognition and enforcement before a signatory court.

  8. The question of assignability of an ICSID Convention award was a substantive issue to be decided under international law and not a matter of enforcement or execution to be dealt with under national law, in this case s.2 of the 1966 Act. Registration of such an award under s.2 of the 1966 Act did not create a legal right that was capable of assignment as a matter of English law, independently of the ICSID Convention award.

Comment

The Court of Appeal found Spain’s failure to abide by its treaty obligation to comply with an ICSID Convention award regrettable. Nonetheless, and notwithstanding contrary views from some foreign courts, it maintained its view that an ICSID Convention award is not assignable.

This litigation may go to the Supreme Court. If so, the outcome will be of significant interest for investment treaty arbitration.

Find out more about our International Arbitration team or contact us today to discuss how we can support you.

You may also be interested in

Your content, your way

Tell us what you'd like to hear more about.

Preference centre

Related views