Key takeaways
OFSI powers under SAMLA 2018
OFSI powers, including to issue licences, are broad and open-ended.
Prejudice suffered due to OFSI decision
Resulting prejudice to designated entity justified if OFSI decision promotes objectives of sanctions regulations.
Procedural unfairness and irrationality
High threshold to prove these against OFSI or other administrative or public body.
In a previous article, we had examined the Administrative Court’s dismissal of VTB Bank’s challenge to an OFSI amended general licence, in relation to what had previously been described as the ‘single biggest financial sanction in history’.
The Court of Appeal has now dismissed VTB Bank’s appeal and upheld the lower court’s decision.
The background facts
VTB Bank, the second largest bank in Russia (VTB) was sanctioned in 2022 following Russia’s invasion of Ukraine. Consequently, these sanctions indirectly extended to VTB’s UK subsidiary, VTB Capital plc (VTBC), via an asset freeze.
VTBC subsequently became insolvent and entered administration. Following their appointment under a licence issued by the UK Office of Financial Sanctions Implementation (OFSI), the Joint Administrators (the JAs) proposed a scheme of arrangement that they considered to be in the best interests of VTBC’s creditors. VTB was by far the largest creditor, with a proof of debt exceeding GBP 205 million. Despite previous indications to the contrary, VTB: (a) announced that it would vote against the proposed scheme, and (b) shortly afterwards, commenced direct enforcement action against VTBC’s assets in Russia.
OFSI subsequently issued an amended licence (the Amended Licence) under which VTB’s voting power was reduced to reflect the value of any assets it had seized through its enforcement action in Russia.
VTB challenged OFSI’s decision to issue the Amended Licence in the Administrative Court on six grounds, three procedural and three substantive.
The Administrative Court decision
VTB’s application for administrative review of the Amended Licence was dismissed in its entirety. The first instance judge found nothing unlawful in OFSI's decision that would justify the Court setting it aside. The licensing power, as it was exercised here, served a legitimate purpose and fitted the statutory framework.
The Administrative Court held that OFSI had acted within its powers in seeking to facilitate the orderly winding up of VTBC and protect its unsanctioned creditors. On the individual challenge grounds, the Administrative Court held that there had been no breach of Article 6 of the European Convention on Human Rights (ECHR) which protects the right to a fair trial, no irrationality in the challenged provisions, no procedural unfairness, no breach of policy, and no failure by OFSI to obtain the information necessary to make its decision.
VTB appealed the Administrative Court’s judgment to the Court of Appeal on four grounds:
In issuing the Amended Licence, OFSI had acted for an improper purpose by prejudicing VTB’s rights as a creditor in VTBC’s insolvency, contrary to the principle in Padfield -v- Minister of Agriculture and Fisheries [1968] AC 997, according to which a public authority or minister that are granted discretionary power by statute must exercise that power to promote, and not to frustrate or thwart, the policy, objects, and purpose of the governing legislation.
The Amended Licence was unreasonable and irrational because it required the use of historic exchange rates, resulting in an overvaluation of the deductions made in respect of VTBC’s assets seized by VTB in Russia, and prohibited the JAs from making provision in respect of those deductions.
The Amended Licence unlawfully interfered with VTB’s right to have its interests in the insolvency determined in accordance with insolvency law, contrary to Article 6 ECHR.
OFSI had failed to consult VTB before issuing the Amended Licence.
The Court of Appeal decision
The Court of Appeal characterised the Padfield ground as the ‘central point to [VTB’s] appeal’. VTB contended that OFSI, by issuing the Amended License, had extended the scope of sanctions imposed on VTB from the measures imposed to expropriation rights. The irrationality and Article 6 ECHR grounds were also considered by the Court of Appeal as ‘[expressing] the Padfield ground in a different form’.
The Court of Appeal, therefore, examined whether the Amended License (a) went beyond the scope permitted by the Sanctions and Anti-Money Laundering Act (SAMLA) 2018, or (b) improperly imposed an expropriatory distribution of VTBC’s insolvency on VTB.
Applying its decision in PJSC National Bank Trust -v- Mints [2023] EWCA Civ 1132, the Court of Appeal held that the sanctions imposed on VTB did not affect VTB’s underlying rights in VTBC’s insolvency, provided that VTB did not breach the relevant sanctions regulations in exercising those rights. As to whether the Amended Licence expropriated VTB’s rights in the insolvency, the Court of Appeal emphasised that the Amended Licence was purely permissive in nature. Its function was to create an exception to the principal sanctions prohibitions and thereby decriminalise conduct that would otherwise breach UK sanctions.
The Court of Appeal further agreed with HM Treasury that the powers conferred on OFSI under SAMLA 2018 were broad and open-ended. It held that, even if VTB were correct that the Amended Licence had the effect of expropriating its rights in VTBC’s insolvency, such an effect would be consistent with the statutory aims of the UK’s Russia sanctions regime. Accordingly, the Padfield or impropriety ground fell away.
As to Article 6 ECHR, the Court of Appeal agreed with the first instance judge that SAMLA 2018 provided an adequate procedure for judicial oversight. It also reiterated that the Amended Licence was permissive in nature and operated only to authorise conduct that would otherwise be prohibited by the sanctions regime.
On the consultation ground, the Court of Appeal held that procedural fairness did not require OFSI to consult directly every creditor, including VTB, before issuing the Amended Licence, as doing so would have been wholly impracticable.
The Court of Appeal also rejected the irrationality ground. It held that the application of the Amended Licence in the insolvency proceedings was a matter for the Insolvency Court and that any questions arising from its application would need to be determined by that court.
Comment
The Court of Appeal has affirmed that the Amended Licence’s aims were to protect VTBC’s creditors, to the maximum extent possible, in light of the existing sanctions restrictions.
The judgment also emphasises the breadth and open-ended nature of the powers available under the UK sanctions framework. Although a general or specific licence is purely permissive in nature, the Court of Appeal’s reasoning shows that any prejudice suffered by a designated entity as a consequence of conduct authorised by such a licence may nevertheless be consistent with the statutory aims of these sanctions regulations.
Find out more about our Sanctions team or contact us today to discuss how we can support you.

