Shipbuilding contracts: liability for additional costs incurred due to subcontractor insolvency

Article13.11.20267 mins read

Key takeaways

Insolvency of subcontractor

Shipbuilder liable for additional costs incurred, unless contract expressly provides otherwise.

Claim for modification or change

Buyer only liable for costs of modifications that it requests.

Preliminary issue in arbitration

Tribunal should decide the issue conclusively.

Can a builder refuse to deliver a vessel unless the buyer pays, or provides security for, a claim arising from additional costs incurred as a result of the insolvency of one of the builder's own subcontractors?

The Court in this case held that a builder could not refuse delivery on that basis.

The decision confirms that, absent express contractual protection, the builder bears the financial consequences of subcontractor insolvency and cannot recover those costs under Article VI of the Norwegian Shipowners’ Association (NSA) standard form shipbuilding contract, which provides for ‘Modifications and Changes’.

The background facts

The Buyer entered into four materially identical shipbuilding contracts in January 2022, each on a modified NSA form (Contracts).

The project was significantly delayed. The first vessel was delivered in January 2026, the second has been tendered but not yet delivered, and the third and fourth are due late 2026 or early 2027. The same issue arises on each hull.

Shortly after the contracts were signed, one of the Builder's subcontractors became insolvent and its work was taken over by others. The Builder claimed additional costs of about €10.8 million in respect of the first hull, with similar claims made or to be made on the others.

The relevant contractual provisions

Article III (1) of the Contracts provides for a contract price of €28.42 million.

Pursuant to Article III (1), where the amount due on delivery is disputed, the Buyer pays the undisputed part, and the disputed balance is either paid against a guarantee from the Builder or, if the Builder declines to provide one, secured by a guarantee from the Buyer. Delivery then proceeds and the dispute is resolved separately in arbitration. Because any sum within the mechanism must be paid or secured before delivery, its scope is of considerable commercial significance to both parties.

Article III (3) provides for the final instalment of €22,736 million to be paid on delivery ‘plus any increase… due to adjustment of the Contract Price hereunder’.

The first paragraph of Article VI (1) (Modifications of Specification) governs modifications made ‘by request from the Buyer' and agreed in writing.

The second paragraph provides that, where changes are made without such written agreement, or where the Builder fails to notify the Buyer in writing without undue delay that a change will require an increase in price, the Builder is not entitled to any increase.

Article II (4) permits the Builder to subcontract but provides that it remains ‘fully liable for the due performance of such work as if done by the Builder’.

The arbitration proceedings

The Builder’s claim for the additional costs incurred due to subcontractor insolvency was put as damages for breach of contract, alternatively as a price increase for a modification under Article VI. The Buyer disputed the claim and maintained that the additional sum claimed did not come within the scope of that provision.

The dispute went to arbitration.

The Tribunal consolidated the four arbitrations and sought to determine, as a preliminary issue, the question of whether, as a condition of delivery, the Builder was entitled to require the Buyer to pay, or provide security for, the disputed claims.

In its partial final award, the Tribunal held that a damages claim for breach of contract that was not a claim for an adjustment of the contract price did not come within Article III (3).

It also found that the Builder had an arguable case that the costs arising out of the subcontractor’s were a modification or change within Article VI (I). However, the Tribunal decided that it was unable to determine the issue conclusively until full evidence and submissions had been filed.

The effect was that an undetermined claim could still be relied upon to withhold delivery unless the Buyer paid or secured it.

The Buyer appealed.

The Commercial Court decision

The Court held that the Tribunal should have made a conclusive determination when dealing with the matter as a preliminary issue, rather than simply deciding the Builder had an arguable case. In the Court’s view, the parties had had sufficient time to plead their cases and adduce their evidence. In any event, the Court stated that evidence as to post-insolvency events was irrelevant in deciding the true meaning and effect of the Contract, even if the cost to the Builder increased as a result of the subcontractor’s insolvency.

The key contractual wording was the second paragraph of Article VI (1), which states as follows:

If modifications or changes are made without such written agreement as aforesaid, or if the Builder fails to notify the Buyer in writing without undue delay that there are modifications or changes which will require an increase in the Contract Price, delayed delivery, changes in the Vessel's characteristics or other changes in the Contract, the Builder will not be entitled to any increase in the Contract Price, adjustment of Delivery Date or other adjustments, and the Contract will remain unchanged.

The Court rejected the Builder’s argument that, properly construed, this provision allowed a builder that gave timely notice to make modifications or changes and recover their cost. Principally:

  1. This construction left unanswered what would happen if the buyer objected to the change. On the Builder's case, a builder could make changes over the buyer's objection, increase the price and require payment or security before delivery. That was unlikely to have been what the parties had intended, particularly since every other change mechanism in Article VI depend on the buyer's consent or approval.

  2. Article VI (1) was concerned with changes to ‘the work to be performed by the Builder’. Under Article II (4) and the specification, work performed by a subcontractor was treated, as between the parties, as work performed by the Builder, for which the Builder remained fully responsible. Where a subcontractor failed and the Builder performed the work itself or engaged a replacement subcontractor, that was only a change to the method or performance rather than a modification of the work to be done on the vessel.

  3. The second paragraph of Article VI (1) was concerned only with the consequences of buyer-requested changes. The insolvency costs were therefore not an ‘adjustment of the Contract Price hereunder’, and the Buyer could not be required to pay or secure them as a condition of delivery.

Comment

The pay-or-secure mechanism in the NSA form is intended to allow vessels to be delivered while disputes are resolved. As this case makes clear, it is not a means by which a builder can pass its own supply chain risk to the buyer at the point of delivery. With three hulls still to be delivered, the issue may well return, and it remains to be seen whether permission to appeal will be sought.

Find out more about our Shipping expertise or contact us today to discuss how we can support you.

You may also be interested in

Your content, your way

Tell us what you'd like to hear more about.

Subscribe to our news and insights

Related views