Urban Splash and Remediation Contribution Orders: historic compliance, modern standards and human rights

Article12.11.20267 mins read

Key takeaways

Building Regulations compliance not determinative

Contemporaneous compliance with Building Regulations is not determinative of exposure to an RCO.

Government exposure

Government’s role in the building safety crisis should be considered on all RCO claims.

Convention Rights not a separate defence

Convention Rights do not operate as a freestanding basis for resisting an RCO, separate from the just and equitable assessment.

On 5 November 2026 the First-tier Tribunal handed down a significant decision on Remediation Contribution Orders (RCOs) - Secretary of State for Housing, Communities and Local Government v Urban Splash and others. An RCO under section 124 of the Building Safety Act 2022 (BSA) enables the Tribunal to require a developer, landlord or associated company to contribute towards the costs of remedying building safety defects.

The Tribunal addressed several issues, including the meaning of ‘relevant defect’, the test of association and how the ‘just and equitable’ test interacts with the respondents’ convention rights. This article focuses on the following three issues:

  • whether a feature can be a ‘relevant defect’ if it complied with the Building Regulations and standards in force when the building was built

  • the relevance of historic regulatory compliance, and of the government’s role in regulatory failures, to the just and equitable test and

  • the extent to which the Tribunal should consider Convention rights.

Factual background

The Applicant was the Secretary of State for Housing, Communities and Local Government.

The Respondents included Urban Splash Ltd (R1) and 10 other companies argued to be associated with it for the purposes of section 124 BSA. Urban Splash Ltd was the developer of seven Manchester residential buildings: Burton Place, Chips, Moho, The Box Works and the Three Towers (Christabel, Emmeline and Sylvia). The buildings were developed between 2000 and 2008.

Following post-Grenfell investigations, extensive fire-safety defects were identified across the buildings, and remediation works exceeding £60 million were undertaken. Approximately £51.5 million was funded through the Building Safety Fund (BSF).

As is stated at paragraph four the overarching issue was:

‘…should the remediation costs funded by the taxpayer continue to be borne by the taxpayer, or should liability for all or part of them be transferred to the developer and/or to various entities alleged to be associated with it?’

The Decision

The buildings were all found to contain relevant defects relating to fire safety and the remediation schemes represented reasonable responses. Further, the Tribunal found that aspects of the original construction failed to satisfy the regulatory requirements applicable when the buildings were developed.

The Tribunal made RCOs in relation to each of the seven buildings against the First, Second, Third, Fourth (R1 to R4) and Eleventh Respondents in the sum of £46,500,650, for which those Respondents were held jointly and severally liable. The applications against the Fifth, Sixth, Seventh and Tenth Respondents were dismissed, and the applications against the Eighth and Ninth Respondents were withdrawn following a settlement. We will prepare a separate article on the application of the test of association.

In applying the just and equitable test, the Tribunal reduced the BSF-funded expenditure by 10% to reflect the government’s shared responsibility for the building safety crisis, as identified in the Hackitt Review and the Grenfell Tower Inquiry Phase 2 Report.

Section 124 of the BSA: the statutory requirements

Section 124 confers a discretionary power on the Tribunal to make an RCO for the purpose of meeting ‘costs incurred or to be incurred in remedying, or otherwise in connection with, relevant defects …. relating to the relevant building’.

To obtain an RCO, an interested person (the applicant) must establish that:

  • the building is a relevant building, namely a building in England containing at least two dwellings and standing at least 11 metres high or five storeys

  • the building contains relevant defects, being defects arising as a result of anything done or not done in connection with relevant works carried out in the 30 years before 28 June 2022 that cause a building safety risk, meaning a risk to people’s safety arising from the spread of fire or the collapse of the building

  • the costs claimed have been, or will be, incurred in remedying those defects or otherwise in connection with them, including investigating and mitigating them

  • the respondent is a developer or landlord of the building, or a body corporate or partnership associated with either of them and

  • it is just and equitable in all the circumstances for the respondent to bear those costs.

Significantly, liability does not depend upon proof of negligence, breach of contract or any other conventional cause of action. The question is whether the statutory criteria are met and whether it is fair for the respondent(s), rather than the public purse or leaseholders, to bear the costs.

A broad definition of ‘relevant defects’

The Tribunal concluded that defect is a ‘broad concept which is apt to include any deficiency in a building assessed by reference to current building standards.’ (para. 89). The following points are of note:

  1. The degree, or tolerability, of risk is not relevant to whether a defect causes a building safety risk. The Tribunal agreed with the President of the Lands Chamber in Edgewater (Stevenage) that “the reference to ‘a risk’ does not refer to any level of risk and is not graduated. It refers to any risk.” The level of risk is instead relevant when assessing what remediation is required.

  2. Defects are not to be assessed solely by reference to the Building Regulations and guidance in force at the time of original construction and may be assessed against current building safety standards and expectations.

  3. Compliance with building standards at the time of construction is relevant but not determinative, so a feature may constitute a defect even if it was thought to comply with prevailing standards when built.

  4. The Tribunal rejected the argument that this broad interpretation opens the door to unnecessary and disproportionate remediation being funded, noting that a Tribunal may decide it is ‘not just and equitable to make such an order in respect of costs incurred in remedying a relevant defect where it considers those costs were unnecessarily incurred’. On the facts, the Developer did not establish a clear, technically viable and cheaper alternative remedial scheme.

Historic regulatory compliance, government responsibility and the just and equitable test

On the facts, the Tribunal held that all seven buildings contained relevant defects.

In reaching the finding that all seven buildings contained relevant defects, the Tribunal accepted that the government’s role in regulatory failures was relevant to the just and equitable test. It said that, had the buildings been constructed in accordance with the building regulations and statutory guidance at the time, ‘a reduction of approximately 20% would then have represented the outer limit of any adjustment which could properly be made’ (para. 701). This was described as a practical ceiling on the exercise of the Tribunal’s discretion in that hypothetical scenario, rather than a figure to which a compliant developer would automatically be entitled.

Because the buildings did not comply with the standards of the time, the Developer could not argue that it had merely complied with a defective regulatory framework. The Tribunal therefore applied a reduction of 10%, and only to the BSF-funded expenditure. It remains to be seen how this approach will be applied where the Applicant is not the Secretary of State.

The just and equitable test and Convention rights

Section 3(1) Human Rights Act 1998 provides that, so far as it is possible to do so, primary legislation must be read and given effect in a way which is compatible with Convention rights.

The Respondents did not challenge the general validity of section 124 of the BSA. Instead, the argument was that section 124 must be read compatibly with Convention rights, so that, even if the Tribunal considered it just and equitable to make an RCO, it could not do so if that would breach Convention rights. They argued that making RCOs would unlawfully interfere with their rights under Article 6 (right to a fair trial) and/or Article 1 of the First Protocol (A1P1) (peaceful enjoyment of possessions).

In regard to A1P1, the issue before the Tribunal was whether the Convention Rights operate as a freestanding basis for resisting an RCO, separate from the just and equitable assessment.

The Tribunal rejected the submission that Convention rights require it to apply any legal test distinct from that already supplied by section 124. In reaching this decision, the Tribunal questioned whether there would ever be circumstances in which a contrary approach would be appropriate:

'In practical terms, therefore, it is difficult to envisage circumstances in which a Tribunal, having fully considered all matters bearing upon fairness, burden and proportionality, could conclude that an order is just and equitable whilst simultaneously regarding the same order as a disproportionate interference with Convention rights. The statutory discretion already requires the evaluative assessment upon which proportionality depends'

The Tribunal also rejected the Respondents’ reliance on Article 6.

Conclusion

Based on the three issues discussed in this article, the key points for developers are:

  1. A feature can be a relevant defect notwithstanding that it complied with regulatory standards at the time of construction, provided that it causes a building safety risk.

  2. Any level of risk suffices to establish a building safety risk. The level of risk is relevant to what remediation is required, and a respondent challenging the remedial scheme should be prepared to establish a clear, technically viable and cheaper alternative.

  3. Historic regulatory compliance does not prevent a feature being a relevant defect, but it is relevant to the just and equitable test. Where buildings complied with the standards of the time, the Tribunal indicated that a reduction of approximately 20% to reflect the government’s responsibility would be the outer limit; where they did not, as in Urban Splash, a smaller reduction (here 10%, applied to BSF-funded expenditure) may be made.

  4. Convention rights arguments are unlikely to succeed as a separate defence. Proportionality points should instead be deployed within the just and equitable test.

Find out more about our Construction and Engineering team or contact us today to discuss how we can support you.

Your content, your way

Tell us what you'd like to hear more about.

Subscribe to our news and insights

Related views